MoleditPy PySCF Calculator Plugin Tutorial

4. Scanning SN2 Reaction and Finding Transition State

(Level of Theory: B3LYP/ma-def2-svp)

Objective

Using the SN2 substitution reaction between chloromethane (CH3Cl) and bromide ion (Br-) as an example, we will perform a reaction coordinate scan (Relaxed Scan) to estimate the energy barrier. Furthermore, using that structure as an initial guess, we will perform a Transition State (TS) calculation and frequency analysis to confirm the imaginary frequency.

Procedure

Step 1: Drawing and Arranging Molecules

  1. Draw Molecules:
    • Draw Chloromethane (CH3Cl).
    • Draw a Bromide ion (Br-) nearby.
  2. 3D Conversion:
    • Click "Convert 2D to 3D" on the toolbar to convert to a 3D structure.
    Molecule drawing and 3D conversion
  3. Position Adjustment:
    • Use the "3D Edit > Move Group..." tool to place Br- on the backside attack position of the carbon atom (opposite to Cl).
    Group Move
  4. Bond Distance Adjustment:
    • Use the "3D Edit > Adjust Bond Length..." tool to set the C-Br distance to 2.8 Å.
    Distance adjustment 2.8A

Step 2: Relaxed Scan Calculation

  1. Launch PySCF Calculator:
    • Open Extensions > PySCF Calculator.
  2. Scan Configuration:
    • Set Mode to Relaxed Surface Scan.
    • Click the "Configure Scan" button and set the Distance tab as follows:
      • Start: 2.8 Å
      • End: 1.96 Å
      • Steps: 5
    • This setting calculates the process of Br approaching C.
    Scan Config settings
  3. Level of Theory Settings:
    • Method: RKS (B3LYP)
    • Basis: ma-def2-svp
    • Note: For anion calculations, basis sets containing diffuse functions (like ma-def2-svp) are recommended. It takes longer than STO-3G.
  4. Run Calculation: Click "Run Calculation". Please wait as it takes some time.

Step 3: Energy Diagram and TS Estimation

  1. Check Results:
    • After calculation finishes, check the Energy Diagram. An energy barrier (mountain-shaped graph) should be displayed.
    • Press the animation play button to see the reaction process.
    Energy Profile Scan Animation
  2. Select TS Candidate:
    • Click the Highest Point on the graph.
    • This reflects the structure of that step in the main window. This serves as a good initial structure for the Transition State (TS).
    Select TS Candidate

Step 4: Transition State (TS) Calculation + Freq

  1. Change Calculation Settings:
    • Return to the Calculation tab.
    • Change Job Type to TS Optimization + Frequency.
    • Do not change other settings (B3LYP / ma-def2-svp).
    TS Calculation Setup
  2. Run Calculation: Click "Run Calculation" again.

Step 5: Confirm Imaginary Frequency

  1. Check Vibrational Modes:
    • After calculation completion, check the Vibrational Modes list.
    • Confirm that there is exactly one Imaginary Frequency (negative frequency). This indicates a transition state.
    • Select that mode and confirm via animation that atoms are moving along the reaction coordinate.
    Check Imaginary Frequency Imaginary Frequency Animation
Calculation of Activation Energy:
Comparison of energy is required for calculating the activation energy. (Note: 1 Hartree ≈ 627.5 kcal/mol)

(Note: Since the calculation is performed in a vacuum, the profile becomes a double-well type. Also, the transition state might be more stable than the reactants.)